Behind the JEA Sale: Mike Hightower, Mike Tolbert, and Mike Miller's Insights
Welcome back to Mikes on Mic!
Today we are again talking about the attempted sale of JEA, Jacksonville's public utility service and the four-year prison sentence handed down on former JEA CEO Aaron Zahn. We'll be talking about Steve Busey's year-long investigation that reviewed over 600,000 documents, ultimately pointing to former Mayor Lenny Curry's significant involvement in the plan to sell JEA.
We’ll also discuss the inspiring stories of Our Jax members and other community heroes who united to prevent the sale of JEA, including then-council president Scott Wilson, Ethics Officer Carla Miller, and prominent media figures who unveiled the story and kept the community informed.
00:00 JEA board turmoil and potential sale.
05:11 Paul McElroy was a popular professional. City hall corruption and secretive meetings.
07:17 JEA PR campaign, Zahn scare tactics, Curry.
10:07 Mayor dodges indictment, implicated in JEA scandal.
16:22 Ad got lots of statewide attention and press.
20:02 Group representing lineman worked to right wrong.
22:34 Thank God, nightmare over, JEA progress.
24:26 Hightower lost, discussed mayor's role and budget.
29:02 Al Kennard pivotal in municipal problem-solving reputation.
31:52 Expressing gratitude, looking forward to next week.
Tune in to the show on your favorite Podcasting platform and on MikesOnMic.com
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/mikes-on-mic/id1697258731
Spotify link: https://open.spotify.com/show/1osbkLvqreSJPXmfaubY1M?si=yVwAAnw1TmSSzZnZ3vM8sA
Connect with us on Social:
Youtube Channel: http://youtube.com/@mikesonmic
Facebook Page link: http://facebook.com/mikesonmic
Enjoy!
[00:00:00] Mike, Mike, Mike, Mike
[00:00:04] Mikes on Mic, a conversation about politics, government and Jacksonville with 50 year opinion
[00:00:10] leaders Mike Hightower, Mike Tolbert and award-winning broadcaster and longtime political
[00:00:16] observer Mike Miller.
[00:00:18] Welcome to another episode of Mikes on Mic.
[00:00:20] I'm Mike Miller.
[00:00:21] I'm here in studio today but my colleagues Mike Hightower and Mike Tolbert are both
[00:00:25] in their respective out of state home.
[00:00:27] Well, Tolbert's not really out of state but it seems like if you ever have to drive there.
[00:00:33] But nevertheless they're at their locations and I'm here at mine.
[00:00:35] We have no guests today.
[00:00:36] It's going to be just the three of us talking about some of the issues of the day.
[00:00:40] But we thought we would kind of bring the final chapter of JEA and talk about the
[00:00:46] Aaronson issue and the of course four years of prison that he has now been sentenced
[00:00:52] to.
[00:00:53] One of the questions we want to talk about here today is what role if any did Mayor Lenny
[00:00:58] Curry play in this entire fiasco?
[00:01:01] And with that Mr. Tolbert kick it off for us.
[00:01:04] Well, you know Mikes it does seem like it's been a slow moving train wreck.
[00:01:09] This first started in 2017 and I think the first public knowledge of it or hint
[00:01:19] was when Curry all of a sudden abruptly removed all the members of the JEA board and then
[00:01:26] put his old buddies on there headed by Tom Petway, a big Curry donor, a big Republican
[00:01:33] donor and a community icon.
[00:01:36] And Petway immediately became chair of the board and then served for a year and
[00:01:41] then a year after he got there after his first year he did a mic drop.
[00:01:46] He resigned in a meeting and announced that he thought that the JEA should explore the
[00:01:52] sale of selling itself.
[00:01:57] So that took one year.
[00:02:02] Mayor Curry then put an unknown guy named Aaron Zahn on the board to replace Petway.
[00:02:09] Zahn stayed on the board just a little bit but once Paul McElroy was run off by
[00:02:14] the mayor, then Zahn resigned from the board and decided he wanted to and then applied
[00:02:21] for interim CEO of the JEA and the board made him interim CEO and then later the
[00:02:27] council made him the CEO of the JEA.
[00:02:33] You know Mike, I was thinking about this.
[00:02:37] I can't imagine what it was like for you to be a top executive at JEA during all this.
[00:02:44] You were there senior vice president of governmental affairs.
[00:02:48] You were very close to Paul McElroy and one of his top people and to watch all
[00:02:54] this and see what was going on, it had to be hell on wheels for you.
[00:02:59] Well that's put it mightily and nobody put that in context if y'all remember correctly.
[00:03:04] I spent 16 years as a board member and four of those years as a chair and then
[00:03:10] when I retired from Blue Cross Blue Shield came back to JEA as you just said
[00:03:15] as head of government relations.
[00:03:18] So I was there when Zahn, when the mayor was putting pressure and basically
[00:03:25] let's call it spade to spade.
[00:03:29] Curry ran Paul McElroy off.
[00:03:31] I mean he was, they just put a lot of pressure on him and then all of a sudden
[00:03:35] Paul comes back from a meeting with the mayor and said guys I'm going to retire.
[00:03:40] Anyway he didn't ever said it.
[00:03:42] It was real clear what happened and so to put this in context to show you what
[00:03:47] happened was they made Melissa Dykes the interim.
[00:03:55] So and Zahn was on the board if you remember correctly.
[00:03:59] So on that was a Friday.
[00:04:01] So on Friday of April 13th Zahn resigns on a Friday afternoon after at five o'clock
[00:04:09] he resigns from the board April 13th.
[00:04:12] On April 17th following Tuesday the board comes together and moves Melissa off as
[00:04:20] interim CEO and unanimously puts Zahn on.
[00:04:27] And then it started from there and she said from that point on it just was
[00:04:36] picking up on what Tom Petway said.
[00:04:39] Zahn was made real clear that they wanted to sell GEA.
[00:04:44] There were some of us on senior staff that didn't agree with it,
[00:04:48] didn't think it was going to happen.
[00:04:51] There's at least two of us that raised the issue that kept saying I
[00:04:54] don't think this is going to pass candidly.
[00:04:57] He told me that the mayor told him they had to he said not to worry the mayor
[00:05:02] has got the 10 votes.
[00:05:03] I mean that is a quote which I gave to the law enforcement FPI and all that.
[00:05:10] It was not it was not good.
[00:05:11] Paul McElroy was credible professional that everyone liked him and it started
[00:05:18] downhill downhill from there.
[00:05:21] We'll get into some of the folks that I think were complicit.
[00:05:26] It starts at City Hall all the way through it.
[00:05:28] The one thing that I want to remind everybody that was that's brought in to
[00:05:32] underscore your point Mike when they kept saying how was this happening
[00:05:38] during the last few weeks that I was there when the pine and a couple of
[00:05:41] the folks said I don't think this is going to happen.
[00:05:43] Zahn used to brag that he had a badge and would wear it.
[00:05:48] They got him into the back door of City Hall and Brad that he had been into
[00:05:53] City Hall during this time over 200 times.
[00:06:00] I left on June 10th which was a Monday and on Tuesday June 11th they were
[00:06:06] named senior staff Zahn and the new consultants that they were hired for
[00:06:10] government relations went off site to talk about the plot plan.
[00:06:14] You know, let me put some context around this Mike Hightower.
[00:06:18] People need to also remember back then Curry controlled a great majority of
[00:06:26] the city council members so when he told Zahn he had the votes there was
[00:06:31] no question about it but he had Tim Baker his consultant they control
[00:06:35] City Council there were a lot of City Council members that sat there like
[00:06:39] deaf dumb and blind while this was going on.
[00:06:42] Complicit in some ways I think.
[00:06:44] Yes so it was so when you talk about complicit that's the main word
[00:06:51] throughout this whole thing.
[00:06:53] City Council, the board that he put in that the mayor put in place,
[00:06:58] the senior staff that stayed there that went behind closed doors on that
[00:07:03] Tuesday June 11th and then the lawyers and the consultants that they
[00:07:09] hired in town to pull off it they were all complicit.
[00:07:12] Those are the ones as I talk about that slipped the book.
[00:07:17] The public relations PR campaign for selling JEA really picked up steam
[00:07:23] back in 2019 when Zahn started telling board members that the sky
[00:07:27] was falling and that there would have to be a 29 percent cut in the
[00:07:31] workforce and a 26 percent increase in rates for the utility if they
[00:07:38] were to quote survive.
[00:07:39] The death spiral I believe is the term that was used for it at the
[00:07:44] time then that summer while protesting that he had no plans was
[00:07:48] not involved in the sale of JEA Mayor Curry at the time said he
[00:07:52] would use the sale proceeds to pay off bond debt and invest what
[00:07:56] was left so it certainly sounds to me like while he knew nothing
[00:08:00] about this he was already planning on how he was going to spend the
[00:08:03] dollars that they were going to end up getting for the sale of
[00:08:07] JEA.
[00:08:08] Why do you think Curry was not part of this at least legally?
[00:08:11] Why wasn't he indicted and what do you think will be his legacy as
[00:08:16] a result of this?
[00:08:17] And you guys can go ahead and start Mr. Hightower.
[00:08:20] I think there's a couple there's a couple questions that I
[00:08:22] gather to divide them.
[00:08:25] There is no way possible that Zahn would have proceeded with
[00:08:29] this if Curry had not been.
[00:08:34] Curry was not aware of it.
[00:08:35] Can I interrupt Mike?
[00:08:37] Can I interrupt you just for a question in that?
[00:08:40] Would you say that Petway also had talked perhaps to Curry prior
[00:08:46] to him dropping the mic and leaving the JEA board so that
[00:08:50] this whole plan would be executed in the way that we get to
[00:08:55] what they hope to be the final result?
[00:08:59] That I don't know.
[00:09:00] I you know what I I don't know.
[00:09:05] Yeah probably.
[00:09:06] Yeah yeah it probably because when he said we should consider
[00:09:10] it Paul McElroy had never Paul McElroy was the executive
[00:09:15] director in all those years that I was on the board.
[00:09:18] I never heard Paul talk about that and when I was brought on
[00:09:21] board when Petway dropped the mic Paul had never mentioned
[00:09:26] that to me and I was part of his senior's team.
[00:09:29] So that came out of came out of the blue.
[00:09:31] So I think Mike is probably right on that.
[00:09:36] Curry had to be a part of it.
[00:09:38] Zahn would not have made Zahn would not have gone one step
[00:09:42] without checking with Curry.
[00:09:44] Curry had put him on the board and like I said.
[00:09:49] It was his Curry's board that when Zahn resigned on the
[00:09:55] board on Friday and the board elects makes him
[00:09:58] unanimously on Tuesday the interim CEO there's no way that
[00:10:04] Curry was not a part of all this.
[00:10:07] You know we'll probably we'll probably never know why he
[00:10:11] wasn't didn't get indicted or whatever but there are some
[00:10:15] things we we do know and some of it is you know he
[00:10:18] double-taught he obfuscated and he stretched the truth
[00:10:23] the outright lied.
[00:10:25] Well the J.E.A.
[00:10:27] investigative report done by Steve Busey for the City
[00:10:31] Council really if you go back and look at that it may
[00:10:35] be very clear that Curry and his administration were
[00:10:39] involved from the very get-go wouldn't have happened
[00:10:41] at all without worry.
[00:10:44] And one year after one year after investigating this
[00:10:47] claim for the City Council the report released was
[00:10:51] released by the City Council in January of 2021
[00:10:56] taking a year reviewing six hundred thousand documents
[00:10:59] as I recall and interviewing dozens of witnesses and when
[00:11:03] it was released if you remember it put a bullseye
[00:11:06] right on the mayor.
[00:11:10] Yeah let me let me and let me remind everybody what
[00:11:14] happened they paid they Busey did the report members
[00:11:20] of the City Council were on that special report and if
[00:11:22] you remember Mike Tolbert one of the things that
[00:11:24] was so exasperating about that was that when the
[00:11:28] report came back to the City Council just to show how
[00:11:32] complicit everybody was involved they never
[00:11:35] discussed it guys they never discussed it all they
[00:11:38] did was there was a motion that the Steve Busey
[00:11:41] report should be made a part of the record.
[00:11:45] It was passed unanimously and nothing was ever
[00:11:48] talked about and I was if you remember and at
[00:11:52] that point a lot of us which got to we'll be
[00:11:55] talking about this shortly about our Jax we just
[00:11:58] said this is an inside deal it's totally bait
[00:12:03] but all that went in there and I can just
[00:12:05] remember bringing it up never talked about it all
[00:12:09] the documents all the good work that Steve Busey
[00:12:12] and the committee did nothing it just made part
[00:12:14] of the record.
[00:12:16] Well you know as for Curry's legacy I'm sure
[00:12:20] there are places in Jacksonville where he can
[00:12:23] go and people still think he was a good mayor
[00:12:27] but I'm old enough to remember when Hayden
[00:12:31] Burns was the mayor and the legacy he left and
[00:12:35] in my humble opinion I think Curry is the most
[00:12:38] least perhaps the least respected mayor of
[00:12:41] Jacksonville since Hayden Burns and I think
[00:12:44] that's his at least that's part of his
[00:12:45] legacy.
[00:12:47] Well I think also is Mike is to underscore
[00:12:52] that when you go back to the Hayden Burns
[00:12:54] saying most of those records and the newspaper
[00:12:57] articles aren't there anymore but now all you
[00:12:59] got to do is Google JEA or Lenny Curry
[00:13:02] and I'm not sure anything's going to pop up
[00:13:05] good about Lenny Curry except that he puts
[00:13:08] on on he put a board together.
[00:13:13] He was part of that deal and then he pulled
[00:13:15] plug when there was an outcry.
[00:13:18] His legacy will always be he tried to sell
[00:13:22] JEA and it didn't work out.
[00:13:26] That's his legacy.
[00:13:27] Doesn't matter what he tries to explain it
[00:13:29] that's his legacy.
[00:13:31] Eight years.
[00:13:32] Eight years.
[00:13:32] That's his legacy.
[00:13:34] The both of you were members of R-Jacks
[00:13:36] I think a lot of people watching or
[00:13:38] listening probably remember R-Jacks because
[00:13:41] of a lot J-sale which you were basically
[00:13:46] spearheading the opposition to that.
[00:13:49] I didn't realize what role one J-sale played
[00:13:52] or R-Jacks rather played with the JEA sale.
[00:13:55] Can you go through that a little bit?
[00:13:56] What did you guys do for that and how did
[00:13:58] that come about?
[00:14:00] Mr. Talbert love this is Talbert this
[00:14:02] Mr. Talbert story.
[00:14:03] I love listening to it.
[00:14:04] I'll add to it but he's got it down.
[00:14:07] Well if you go back and remember
[00:14:13] there were a lot of people who were
[00:14:14] concerned about the sale in the community
[00:14:17] but we were mostly talking amongst ourselves.
[00:14:20] Jake was about the only one
[00:14:22] politically raising hell about it
[00:14:25] and I remember him saying to me one day
[00:14:28] why am I out here on this limb by myself?
[00:14:31] Where are the rest of the people
[00:14:33] who should be standing up and raising hell about it?
[00:14:36] And so one day I get a call to come
[00:14:40] to a meeting at Randy DeForest's
[00:14:42] Fidelity office about the JDA
[00:14:46] and I didn't know what it was about.
[00:14:47] I mean what was going on?
[00:14:49] This was in November of 2019 I think Hightower.
[00:14:53] Absolutely.
[00:14:54] And so we go to the meeting
[00:14:55] and there's people like Michael Ward in there
[00:14:58] and David Miller and Mike Hightower
[00:15:00] and Aldrich Moran and Sherry McGill.
[00:15:03] I mean just around the table Bobby Stein
[00:15:06] and I'm thinking what the hell am I doing here?
[00:15:09] Well the train was moving so fast.
[00:15:12] This is November now at 2019.
[00:15:15] There was a plan to have a council vote
[00:15:19] in January just a couple of months later
[00:15:22] put a referendum on the ballot
[00:15:24] to approve the sale of the JDA
[00:15:27] and so I learned that we were there
[00:15:30] to start talking about putting together
[00:15:32] a campaign to oppose it.
[00:15:35] Over a period of time we gained momentum,
[00:15:38] things started happening and so the referendum
[00:15:42] got backed away from.
[00:15:44] So we weren't putting on an election,
[00:15:45] we were now trying to stop the sale of the JDA
[00:15:49] and I remember one of the things I remember Hightower,
[00:15:51] toward the end of that meeting,
[00:15:52] I just sat there listening all
[00:15:55] and toward the end of the meeting I raised my hand
[00:15:59] and I said you know Mayor Godbowl
[00:16:01] is about to send in another guest column
[00:16:05] on the sale of the JDA to the Times Union.
[00:16:09] It would really be stronger and nice
[00:16:11] if there could be a full page ad
[00:16:14] and so Michael Ward immediately said I'll pay for it
[00:16:18] and it was a pretty damn strong ad to be honest.
[00:16:22] It got a lot of attention and I remember
[00:16:26] when we were putting the ad together
[00:16:30] I called Michael Ward and I said
[00:16:33] I'm gonna send you a copy of the ad
[00:16:36] so you can approve it and he said
[00:16:38] you think I'm gonna approve anything
[00:16:39] or change anything that Jay Godbowl wants to do?
[00:16:44] I don't know if he felt the same way after the ad
[00:16:51] and that happened sort of like boom boom.
[00:16:53] The ad came out, got a lot of press on the ad,
[00:16:56] not just being in the newspaper,
[00:16:58] it made headlines and was on the news,
[00:17:01] television news.
[00:17:02] And statewide they paid.
[00:17:04] Yeah, but right after that was the next day
[00:17:09] I think was that city council special,
[00:17:12] the special committee meeting of the city council
[00:17:14] that Michael Bowlin chair and Jake
[00:17:18] and Mike Ward both were there
[00:17:20] and that's what Jake told Bowlin
[00:17:23] he was gonna stalk as long as he wanted to.
[00:17:24] He'd been sitting on his ass for a long time
[00:17:26] and he wasn't coming back if y'all remember that.
[00:17:30] Came out as Walker, remember that.
[00:17:34] Well yeah we picked up momentum
[00:17:37] and you're right Mike Miller
[00:17:39] that once it was determined
[00:17:42] we weren't gonna sell the JEA,
[00:17:46] there was a move, there was conversation
[00:17:49] about disbanding our jacks,
[00:17:50] we had done our job.
[00:17:52] But then all of a sudden a lot of Jay stuck
[00:17:54] it would keep sort of sticking its head up
[00:17:57] and so we used what I guess credibility we had gained.
[00:18:04] I would say star power.
[00:18:06] I would call it star power more than I would have
[00:18:09] to be honest.
[00:18:10] You had some pretty influential
[00:18:11] and very, very, very well known people on that group.
[00:18:15] No question about it.
[00:18:16] I wonder what the hell I was doing there.
[00:18:19] No, no it wasn't.
[00:18:21] We all brought something as a team,
[00:18:22] it was a great team effort.
[00:18:23] It was what you think about it,
[00:18:25] it was an incredible team.
[00:18:27] The thing was we were just doing
[00:18:28] what we thought was right.
[00:18:29] Going back to what Ed Austin said,
[00:18:31] you're never wrong if you do the right thing
[00:18:33] for the right reason, period, Barrett.
[00:18:35] Good point, good point.
[00:18:37] You know there were some good guys
[00:18:38] and heroes in all of this as well
[00:18:40] and we really shouldn't forget them
[00:18:42] because we don't want to paint a picture
[00:18:44] that says that everybody was a villain
[00:18:46] in this deceitful program.
[00:18:48] So let's name a few of those people
[00:18:51] who you guys felt specifically
[00:18:54] were really wearing the white hats on this one.
[00:18:58] Well I would suspect Mike Hightower
[00:19:00] and I will probably agree on most of these.
[00:19:02] I made a little list
[00:19:03] and of course it starts with my friend Jay Godbolt.
[00:19:06] It includes Council President Scott Wilson
[00:19:10] who was really strong.
[00:19:12] I mean if it hadn't been for Scott,
[00:19:14] I don't know if you might not have stole the JEA.
[00:19:19] There was Carla Miller
[00:19:21] whose legacy will forever be defined
[00:19:23] by what she did in Atlanta.
[00:19:27] For people who don't recall, by the way,
[00:19:29] Carla was our ethics officer here in the city.
[00:19:31] Ethics, the city's ethics officer.
[00:19:33] Then you had Kyle Billy, the auditor,
[00:19:35] the councilor who's the first one
[00:19:37] that unveiled the PUP plan
[00:19:39] to give those guys millions of bonus dollars.
[00:19:43] There were some members of the city council.
[00:19:45] Not all of them were under the control
[00:19:46] of Curry and complicit.
[00:19:48] Randy DeFore obviously was not.
[00:19:51] Matt Carlucci and Garrett Dennis
[00:19:54] and Brenda Priestley Jackson.
[00:19:55] There were others who were strong and stood up.
[00:19:58] Of course you had our Jacks,
[00:19:59] the members of our Jacks.
[00:20:03] Just to replace that,
[00:20:05] as Sherri McGill, Audra Moran,
[00:20:08] David Miller, Michael Ward, Talbert, myself.
[00:20:14] The other thing is there was
[00:20:15] the attorney that represented the lineman
[00:20:21] and there was a representative from the lineman.
[00:20:26] It was just an incredible group.
[00:20:31] It was wrong what was going on
[00:20:32] and the other thing was we just kept going back
[00:20:35] and I keep going back to what Mike Talbert said
[00:20:39] when we started getting names
[00:20:44] and we had a website.
[00:20:45] He said, you can't over-communicate with the public
[00:20:49] and that was the driving thing.
[00:20:51] We got to reach out and get more folks involved
[00:20:54] and that was one of the things
[00:20:55] that Mike talks about why he was there.
[00:20:58] Mike brought some skills to it
[00:21:00] and when you throw the reputation
[00:21:02] of those people I just talked about
[00:21:04] and the fact was that we were doing it,
[00:21:06] we thought for the right reason
[00:21:07] because we thought what was going on was wrong.
[00:21:10] There was a lack of transparency
[00:21:12] and we just kind of felt like
[00:21:14] it was being run by a group of people
[00:21:16] that were self-serving
[00:21:17] and it was going to be bad for the city
[00:21:20] and that's what drove us.
[00:21:22] Let me finish my message.
[00:21:22] There were a few others too Mike.
[00:21:24] Talbert there were a few others too
[00:21:26] including some of my former colleagues in the media.
[00:21:29] You've got Nate Monroe and Chris Hong
[00:21:31] and they were all over it
[00:21:34] and other members of the media.
[00:21:35] One of my favorites was my friend Pete Carpenter
[00:21:39] who was a retired CEO of CSX.
[00:21:43] Right after Zahn was hired,
[00:21:47] he went crazy about it
[00:21:50] and he called me and he said
[00:21:51] I want to write a letter to the editor.
[00:21:53] Will you help me?
[00:21:54] And I said Pete if you write it
[00:21:56] it's going to be more than a letter to the editor.
[00:21:58] It's going to be a guest column
[00:22:00] but I'll be happy to write it for you
[00:22:03] and one of the things he insisted on saying
[00:22:06] was that this guy Zahn was nothing
[00:22:08] but a snake oil salesman
[00:22:10] and that was the bottom line of that column
[00:22:13] and boy did he call it right.
[00:22:15] Then you've got the federal prosecutors
[00:22:17] who've got this ball rolling
[00:22:18] and kept it rolling and got the conviction
[00:22:21] and then finally you got Judge Davis
[00:22:24] and I want to know what went through your head
[00:22:28] when you heard the verdict
[00:22:29] that Judge Davis handed down given your experiences?
[00:22:34] The first thought was thank God finally.
[00:22:40] Finally.
[00:22:43] And then my second thought was
[00:22:45] all the ones who we have talked about
[00:22:48] that were complicit or knew what was going on
[00:22:51] or were getting some sort of contract
[00:22:55] or something out of it
[00:22:56] that one said he had slipped the foot
[00:22:58] and then I thought about the three or four
[00:23:00] who got a good lawyer,
[00:23:04] probably turned states or federal witness,
[00:23:07] got off the deal altogether
[00:23:10] but it was finally this nightmare was over
[00:23:13] and I think one of the things
[00:23:15] that we talked about when we first started out
[00:23:18] and when we were talking with the folks
[00:23:19] that represented the JEA was that
[00:23:22] when you think of the JEA's been around
[00:23:24] for almost 125 years,
[00:23:26] it's got great dedicated committed people.
[00:23:31] In the lineman alone,
[00:23:33] there are three generations of linemen there.
[00:23:36] By the way, we now have a woman lineman
[00:23:39] we have a female lineman finally
[00:23:40] but there are three generations of linemen right there.
[00:23:43] It's a family.
[00:23:45] But one thing I wanted to say is
[00:23:48] and I want to take it from the Mark Woods column
[00:23:50] that recently ran
[00:23:53] and this is a quote from the column,
[00:23:54] as assistant US attorney A. Dyson Duva said,
[00:23:57] the crime wasn't the attempting sale,
[00:24:01] it was the effort to fleece the city of Jacksonville.
[00:24:04] Duva summed it up that has been reported
[00:24:07] and investigated and deliberated in the last five years
[00:24:10] by saying that the former CEO came up with a bonus plan.
[00:24:13] That's the PUP plan.
[00:24:15] We really haven't talked much about that today
[00:24:17] but the PUP plan and he said,
[00:24:19] he tried to hide it Zahn,
[00:24:21] but he got caught
[00:24:22] and that really kind of put it all in a circle.
[00:24:26] It looks like we've lost Hightower here Mike
[00:24:28] but let's move on if we can
[00:24:30] and hopefully he'll come back in
[00:24:32] and talking about good guys
[00:24:35] and I think we just had an incredible opportunity last week
[00:24:40] to be able to sit down with mayor Donna Deegan
[00:24:43] and talk with her about her first year.
[00:24:47] And we primarily discussed
[00:24:48] for people who haven't seen the show,
[00:24:50] primarily announced or talked
[00:24:52] about the $1.9 billion budget.
[00:24:57] I had some takeaways.
[00:24:58] I want to hear yours too Tolbert.
[00:24:59] Let me start off if I may,
[00:25:02] by starting with what she said
[00:25:06] was her whole role
[00:25:07] and how she saw herself as the mayor
[00:25:09] and she said,
[00:25:10] changing the culture in city hall
[00:25:13] and made a very important point
[00:25:16] by saying that people desperately want to be a part
[00:25:19] of this city government
[00:25:21] but they have felt like they didn't have a voice
[00:25:23] and she wanted to become the voice
[00:25:26] of the people for city government
[00:25:28] which I think was very poignant for her to say that.
[00:25:33] She also, by the way
[00:25:35] and you may recall this,
[00:25:36] quoted Tampa mayor Bob Buckhorn
[00:25:38] who she admires greatly
[00:25:39] and is a good friend
[00:25:40] by saying that as far as running for office
[00:25:43] the best storyteller wins.
[00:25:46] And Mike Tolbert,
[00:25:48] you personify that as a storyteller for yourself
[00:25:51] as well as for candidates
[00:25:52] that you've worked for
[00:25:54] and helping them form their message
[00:25:56] and be successful in forming that message.
[00:26:00] The last thing that she said
[00:26:01] that I wanted to quote here was
[00:26:04] if we can't be a healthful city,
[00:26:07] we can't be a successful city.
[00:26:09] And I thought that was so very important
[00:26:11] as she was talking about healthcare in the city.
[00:26:14] Mike, what about your thoughts?
[00:26:16] Well, I have several.
[00:26:17] One of them is gonna sound kind of self-serving
[00:26:19] but in a lot of ways to me
[00:26:21] she has channeled Jay Godbow.
[00:26:25] She made it very clear
[00:26:28] that she does not like inaction.
[00:26:31] She likes to get things done.
[00:26:34] I recall right after we got to her office,
[00:26:39] Mike Hightower and I came together
[00:26:40] and we were running a little behind.
[00:26:43] But on the way there,
[00:26:44] I told Hightower,
[00:26:45] I said, don't worry about it
[00:26:46] because I've never known a mayor to be on time.
[00:26:50] And then I looked at him
[00:26:52] and I said, well, I'm not sure about Donna
[00:26:54] because she's been in the news business
[00:26:58] and she's been on deadline all her life.
[00:27:01] So no question,
[00:27:02] but we got there.
[00:27:03] We weren't late.
[00:27:04] We were early.
[00:27:05] But we got there and she was in her office
[00:27:07] waiting on us and wanting to talk
[00:27:09] and before we did anything,
[00:27:11] I told her that story
[00:27:13] and she smiled and she said,
[00:27:15] you know, I tell people
[00:27:17] the 11 o'clock news never starts at 1101.
[00:27:22] And she has impressed me as someone who like Jay
[00:27:27] when there was an issue or a problem
[00:27:28] that needed to be solved
[00:27:30] would put all the players in the room together.
[00:27:34] And then the deal was we're not leaving
[00:27:38] until we get this done.
[00:27:40] I don't care what you got coming up
[00:27:42] or what you think you need to be done
[00:27:44] until we get this solved,
[00:27:46] we're gonna stay right here and make it happen.
[00:27:49] And I think she's an action oriented
[00:27:51] kind of an individual.
[00:27:52] I really do.
[00:27:53] Yeah, I think so too.
[00:27:54] And she seems very pleased with her first year
[00:27:57] and I think she looked very optimistic
[00:27:59] as far as moving forward.
[00:28:01] And you're right, she should be.
[00:28:02] It was audacious as it was quoted
[00:28:07] an audacious first year.
[00:28:09] Well, we're gonna wrap things up a little early
[00:28:11] because we've lost Mr. Hightower
[00:28:13] but we don't wanna wrap up this show
[00:28:15] without mentioning and paying tribute
[00:28:18] to two great citizens that we've lost here
[00:28:21] in the last couple of weeks.
[00:28:23] First one is was Al Cunard.
[00:28:27] I knew Al Cunard when I was working
[00:28:30] for the Jacksonville Economic Development Commission
[00:28:31] before I joined the Delaney administration
[00:28:34] back in the year 2000.
[00:28:36] And became pretty close with Big Al.
[00:28:39] I liked him a lot, he seemed to like me a lot
[00:28:42] but boy, I'll tell you there was nothing
[00:28:44] that anyone could ask of him
[00:28:46] that he wasn't ready to jump in with both feet.
[00:28:49] He would move mountains for anybody that he liked
[00:28:53] and anybody that he thought would be good
[00:28:55] for the city of Jacksonville.
[00:28:57] And that's really the impression I got from Al.
[00:29:00] You guys knew him a lot longer than I did, of course.
[00:29:02] Well, you know Al's reputation was
[00:29:06] he would not say no when something couldn't be done
[00:29:09] and I get a lot of credit
[00:29:12] with things that Jake and I did together.
[00:29:15] But I gotta tell you,
[00:29:16] Cunard was there making it happen for me especially
[00:29:19] and for Jake, he was the go-to guy.
[00:29:22] When I remember the first time I met Al
[00:29:24] when I came to Jacksonville in 69
[00:29:27] as a reporter for the Times-Genium covered city hall
[00:29:30] and Al was in streets and highways.
[00:29:32] He wasn't a department in the hour
[00:29:33] even though he was division chief.
[00:29:35] But I found out very quickly
[00:29:38] that when city council members had an issue
[00:29:41] in their district, particularly at a pothole
[00:29:44] or some water drain or in a main bus or something,
[00:29:48] they went directly to Al Cunard
[00:29:50] who didn't have a lot of authority
[00:29:52] but Al made it, he got it all fixed.
[00:29:54] Well, in doing that,
[00:29:55] Al was getting the chitch from himself
[00:29:57] and Mayor Tansley wasn't.
[00:30:01] And so when I went on Tansley's staff a few years later,
[00:30:04] I tried to explain to the hands,
[00:30:08] let Al keep doing his thing
[00:30:09] but make sure those council members know
[00:30:12] that he's doing it because you want him to do it.
[00:30:15] But Al served five mayors,
[00:30:19] I think almost six decades
[00:30:22] and I've known some really good public servants
[00:30:26] but I've never known anybody like Al Cunard
[00:30:30] and his ever-present cigar.
[00:30:34] Another great leader that we lost here recently
[00:30:36] was David Stein.
[00:30:38] Most people in the community probably know David
[00:30:41] because he was the man to introduce Burger King
[00:30:45] to the city of Jacksonville.
[00:30:46] He had the original franchise with that company.
[00:30:49] Pardon me, would you say Mike Tobin?
[00:30:51] The nation, I am sorry.
[00:30:53] You're right.
[00:30:54] I can tell you that in the Jewish community,
[00:30:56] he's probably best known for being the founder
[00:31:00] of the Jacksonville Community Alliance, the JCA
[00:31:03] and I got a very nice note from Adam Chaskin
[00:31:05] who you may recall was on our program
[00:31:08] as part of the organization Together Without Hate
[00:31:12] that we did here on Mike's on Mike
[00:31:14] but he wrote out and said that the JCA
[00:31:17] stands as a testament of David's commitment
[00:31:19] to fostering unity, cultural enrichment
[00:31:22] and support within the community.
[00:31:24] Without this bold vision, our beloved JCA
[00:31:27] would not be what it is today.
[00:31:29] Those doors opened in 1988 and they continue open
[00:31:32] and they're bigger and better than they ever were before
[00:31:35] and really we have lost two great icons
[00:31:38] in this community in the last couple of weeks
[00:31:40] with Al Cunard and David Stein
[00:31:42] and we wish them well and as we say in our community,
[00:31:47] may their memories be a blessing.
[00:31:49] Gentlemen, we're out of time.
[00:31:51] It's been a great half hour.
[00:31:52] Thank you very much.
[00:31:53] I miss you both.
[00:31:54] It's always more fun when we're all together
[00:31:56] in the same studio.
[00:31:57] That way we can kick each other onto the table
[00:31:59] but just pretend like this is a kick
[00:32:02] to both of you guys and thank you very much
[00:32:04] for joining us and thank you for joining us.
[00:32:07] The Mike's on Mike program brought to you
[00:32:08] by the Jacksonville History Center and the fine donors
[00:32:11] who keep the cameras rolling and the lights on.
[00:32:13] Thanks for joining us and we'll see you again next week.
[00:32:17] Mike's on Mike with Mike Tolbert, Mike Hightower
[00:32:20] and Mike Miller can be found
[00:32:21] on your favorite podcasting platform,
[00:32:23] Facebook and YouTube.
[00:32:25] Visit the website at Mike's on Mike.com.
[00:32:29] Join us next time for more conversation
[00:32:31] with Mike's on Mike.

